Fewer sewage spills will be draining into San Francisco Bay from Menlo Park-based West Bay Sanitary District. Baykeeper has successfully settled our long-running lawsuit against West Bay for illegal sewage spills, reaching an agreement that details the agency’s efforts to curb its sewage pollution as a result of Baykeeper’s suit. The Sanitary District’s board of directors approved the settlement January 11.
After Baykeeper brought suit under the Clean Water Act in 2009, West Bay initiated major upgrades to its antiquated sewer system in order to significantly reduce its sewage pollution to the Bay.
According to the settlement agreement, Baykeeper’s suit was a significant factor in West Bay’s decision to implement major upgrades to its system, and the agency is committed to further upgrades in order to achieve a very low rate of sewage spills to San Francisco Bay.
The settlement also requires West Bay to pay $1.4 million to reimburse Baykeeper’s attorneys’ fees and expert costs and to fund projects to benefit Bay water quality. (The projects will conducted by organizations not involved in the suit.)
In May 2011, a U.S. District Court judge found West Bay liable for 21 illegal sewage spills that flowed directly into area creeks and sloughs over the previous five years, with liability on dozens of additional spills to be proven at a trial set for March, 2012. Read more about the May 2011 court decision.
The court victory came after West Bay refused to admit liability for its sewage spills, instead embarking on an extended and expensive litigation strategy to fight Baykeeper’s suit. West Bay raised multiple meritless arguments – such as arguing that its watershed was not covered by the Clean Water Act – and denied the accuracy of its own self-reported spill data.
Baykeeper is excited to have finally achieved our goal of reducing West Bay’s pollution to San Francisco Bay. The agency used to be one of the worst-polluting sewage agencies in the Bay Area, but it has reduced its sewage spills by two-thirds since Baykeeper brought suit.
According to State Water Resources Control Board records, West Bay reported more than 300 sewer spills between 2004 and 2010. As a result, more than 60,000 gallons of sewage flowed into local creeks, sloughs and city drains connected to San Francisco Bay. The sewage polluted popular recreation areas and vital spawning grounds for threatened steelhead trout.
Spills of untreated sewage contain bacteria, viruses and other pathogens. When windsurfers, swimmers, fishermen and others come in contact with water contaminated with sewage, it can cause persistent skin infections and painful stomach disorders. Sewage can also deplete oxygen in the Bay, threatening fish, seals, other sea creatures, and plant life.
West Bay Sanitary District will repair sewer lines in Menlo Park, Atherton, Woodside, Portola Valley, East Palo Alto and unincorporated areas of San Mateo and Santa Clara counties.
Baykeeper is also overseeing settlement agreements compelling major sewer repairs in fourteen other Bay Area cities and sewage districts: Oakland, Alameda, Berkeley, Richmond, El Cerrito, Kensington, Vallejo, San Bruno, South San Francisco, Millbrae, San Carlos, Burlingame, Hillsborough and Burlingame Hills. Read more about Baykeeper's previous legal actions to stop sewage pollution.