At EPA headquarters, salt ponds aren’t water

Apr 15, 2020

In a bizarre act of make believe, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) team in D.C. is claiming that pond water isn’t water. EPA recently decided that the Redwood City salt ponds are land and therefore don't deserve Clean Water Act protection. This is contrary to findings by the EPA's regional San Francisco office. 

The ponds used to be wetlands. If the surrounding levees were removed, the area would return to its natural marshy state. EPA’s decision is a thinly veiled attempt to prevent this from happening, and to allow Cargill—the ponds’ corporate owner—to bypass Clean Water Act safeguards and turn this potential wetland into a parking lot.

Cargill is also setting the stage for costly future disasters since, if developed, the salt pond area would be vulnerable to constant flooding due to sea level rise. Wetlands, on the other hand, would provide a natural buffer to rising seas for existing communities and a home for endangered species.

That’s why Baykeeper is suing the Trump administration and fighting to overturn this decision.

But if Trump’s EPA decision stands, it would set a precedent for corporations to pave other parts of the Bay, including salt ponds in Newark. So we’re partnering with Save the Bay, Citizens Committee to Complete the Refuge, and Committee for Green Foothills to defend this part of the Bay. We’re determined not to let the Trump administration bend our vital clean water laws to allow Cargill to destroy critical Bay wetlands.

The South Bay salt ponds, pictured, are the brightly colored ponds that you can see out the window of a plane flying over the Bay Area. Image by Autonomous Imagery.

Related Content

New Dams? Bad Idea
As multiple California fish species teeter on the brink of extinction, and both commercial and recreational fisheries face imminent collapse, a new project threatens to push them over the edge. The...
Virtually Impossible
This July has registered as the hottest month on Earth, ever. That statistic has appeared in the news a lot lately. It gives me chills every time I hear it, which is somewhat ironic given the triple...
The Supreme Court Muddies Our Waters
Two Idaho property owners were dumping sand and gravel into wetlands—just 300 feet from a lake—when the EPA told them they had to apply for a permit before filling and building on wetlands. Instead...
Join us to hold polluters accountable and defend the Bay DONATE NOW >